The costs of remedial work to address wind noise issues is often quite high, especially when compared to the cost of engaging Windtech Consultants to undertake a desktop wind-induced noise assessment. Façade elements are a common source of wind noise in buildings. Engaging Windtech Consultants at the outset, before the façade elements are fabricated, can avoid very costly rectification work to mitigate wind noise issues in buildings.

Windtech have undertaken substantial internal research on this topic since the mid-1990’s and have completed over 100 investigations since that time. These include a significant number of remedial studies. Our ability to identify problems and cost effective solutions quickly is a direct reflection of our experience.

An example of one such remedial wind-induced noise study was wind-induced noise and vibrations on the horizontal aluminium circular hollow section (CHS) sunshades situated along the top of the façade of the Workzone Building located at 202 Pier Street, Perth (pictured above). Structures such as these have been reported to exhibit large wind induced excitation. These have been due to both vortex-induced excitation and wake interference excitation mechanisms. Structures such as this will be particularly susceptible if they have either low damping or low mass. After testing the sample in the wind-tunnel it was determined that the CHS members were mainly influenced by the resonant response to the vortex shedding frequency.

Several treatment options were proposed including mounting the louvres on rubber connector rings, removing every second circular member from the sample, and having expanding foam inserted to various circular members. Of these the adopted solution was to insert expanding foam into the first and seventh members. The hardened expanding foam within the circular members resulted in a reduction of the natural frequency (which lowered the critical velocity) as well as providing additional damping and mass.

Another example of a remedial wind-induced noise study recently undertaken by Windtech is in relation to the perforated metal screens on the Northern Beaches Hospital Carpark façade (7 storeys – 99m x 33.8m x 23.25m). These punched metal screens tended to generate extremely loud (up to 115dB) high pitch wind noise. Windtech proposed alternative treatment strategies to mitigate the wind noise from the screens. The performance of these was verified through testing in one of our three wind tunnels – first to replicate the on-site conditions then with the effect of the treatment. Two treatment strategies were tested:

The expanded metal screens were most effective in completely eliminating the harmonics between the vortices shed behind the original screens. The punched metal screens with a randomised pattern was also effective for most of the cases and generated a low amplitude noise for one angle of attack in high wind.

Windtech regularly undertakes remedial wind-noise studies due to our demonstrated depth of experience in this field. This enables us to formulate practical solutions at the outset. We recommend a desktop wind noise assessment prior to fabrication to avoid the cost of remediation. If you would like to discuss your current project or have a wind noise problem, please contact one of the following Windtech staff who can provide expert advice in this field:

Dr Nicholas Truong: nicholas@windtechglobal.com

Simon Ronald: Simon@windtechglobal.com

Dr Ahmed Faheem: afaheem@windtechglobal.com

Tony Rofail: trofail@windtechglobal.com

Windtech’s Principal and Director, Tony Rofail, will present at the 7th Annual Vertical Cities conference, broaching on the topic of “Outsmarting the Wind,” where he will present cost effective strategies to enhance the aerodynamic performance of tall buildings. The presentation will draw on Tony’s depth of experience in research and industry specific expertise having headed Windtech Consultants for over 25 years.

Tony will be covering the following topics:• The effect of different wind climates on shape optimisation strategies• When it is feasible to modify dynamic properties to enhance aerodynamic performance for tall buildings.• Cost effective strategies for auxiliary damping for tall buildings.

These topics are designed to aid in the accomplishment of one of the conferences goals: overcoming the challenges in developing vertically integrated supertall buildings.

The conference invites industry experts from around the world and will be taking place between the 7-9th of March in Bangkok. Tony would be happy to meet at this event to discuss ways Windtech can help overcome challenges for your current and future projects. Alternatively you may contact Tony via email via the hyperlink below.

Windtech is delighted to have contributed to both finalists from Singapore: Marina One and Oasia Downtown Hotel. These projects are nominated for the Best Tall Building in Asia & Australasia. In addition, Oasia Downtown Hotel is nominated for the Urban Habitat Award.

 

Windtech supported Singapore’s Marina One project (pictured above) from the early design stages providing advice with regards to the pedestrian wind environment, design wind load effect on the link bridges and the structural frame, including the effect of load transfer between the linked substructures for the residential components. Windtech also modelled the façade cladding pressures. Windtech helped provide solutions to overcome the challenges for a project with large open public spaces between the towers.

Oasia Downtown Hotel in Singapore (pictured above) was nominated for both the Best Tall Building (Asia and Australasia) as well as the Urban Habitat Award. The unique permeable façade incorporates live plants to create a living tower. Windtech were thrilled to be associated with the façade pressure studies in order to facilitate good design on such an innovative project as well as overcoming the challenge of delivering suitable wind conditions for the elevated terraces without impacting the architectural intent.

Windtech have been surpassing expectations with increased demand due to our tailored approach for each project and our robust analysis of wind effects across the globe. Let us demonstrate how we can assist in supporting good design outcomes for your next project. Email us at reception@windtechglobal.com or call us at any of our offices.

Tony Rofail, a director of Windtech Consultants, presented a talk on the issue of development controls for wind environment impacts at the 10th International Urban Design Conference held last week at the Surfers Paradise Marriott, Gold Coast, Australia.

Tony’s key message was the need to adopt appropriate and well defined wind speed criteria based on the type of outdoor activity. A proposal was presented with regards to the trigger for a wind tunnel study – that would be a function of both exposure and building height. A proposal was also put forward for the study area, as a function of the relationship between the height, width and depth of the building envelope.

Tony’s presentation highlighted the importance of allowing flexibility in the building massing but at the same time encouraging positive features for wind comfort and gave examples of the two extremes where no controls have been in place with regards to wind as well as the effect of too much control over building massing and setbacks.

Windtech Consultants have an unrivaled understanding of the level of comfort expected from both the occupants and the general public with regards to wind impacts and the most effective and efficient methods of mitigation.

Windtech have wide experience for both new developments and remedial studies. If you would like to discuss a current project please send your query to reception@windtechglobal.com.

Windtech Consultants has recently overcome a number of design constraints in order to design a liquid damper tank that maximises occupant comfort during high wind events across a broad range of frequencies with less sensitivity to tuning. The bespoke damper design was commissioned for The Independent development which will be one of the tallest all concrete residential towers in Austin, Texas when completed in 2018.

Tight dimensional constraints and the request to utilise a single tank led to Windtech Consultants having to look closely at the basic physics of how damping is generated to explore innovative ideas for a new type of liquid damper. The result was a semi-tuned liquid damper that, when tuned, can provide up to 2% additional damping to the structure but can also provide 0.9% damping at a tuning ratio of 0.8. This is a robust and low-maintenance design performs effectively over a broad range of frequencies.

A unique feature of this damper design is that it can work with the basic overall dimensions of a fire hydrant tank located at the top of the building. This innovative design enables the liquid damper to work in a similar way to a dashpot, using an intermediate platform that engages the lower compartment. The damper performance can be optimised by adjusting the height of the platform within the tank.

CTBUH 2017 Session Spotlight

Ground Plane Environmental Considerations

In addition to the study of the impact of new developments on environmental wind conditions at street level, Windtech Consultants also provides detailed analysis of the potential impact of solar reflectance from the building facade. This includes both the specular reflectance of visible light and thermal reflectance. The specular solar light reflectance potentially impact driver visibility resulting in a potential safety hazard while extreme cases cases of thermal reflectance can result in damage to property or injuries to people.
Aaron Lefcovitch, one of Windtech’s experts in the study of Solar Reflectivity impacts from buildings will be presenting on this topic at the upcoming CTBUH Conference in Sydney. Aaron’s presentation will outline the current best techniques that help us understand the scope and impact of both Solar Visible Light and Solar Heat reflectance. The presentation will also include examples of practical ways to mitigate any negative consequences that a tower might have on a city’s ground plane.

Session 6H:
“Ground Plane Environmental Considerations”

31 Oct 2017
11:15 AM – 12:45 PM

Click Here for Full Program

Featured Speaker:

Aaron Lefcovitch

Associate Director, Windtech Consultants
“Prediction and Mitigation of the Solar Reflectivity Impacts of Tall Buildings”

Register for the Conference Now!

See this presentation and more: Sydney, Melbourne & Brisbane · 30 Oct–3 Nov 2017

Windtech are proud to be have provided the wind engineering and other services for all categories that involve tall buildings:

Windtech undertook a range of wind engineering studies for the development at 5 Martin Place. During the planning approval phase a study of pedestrian comfort was completed which included the wind conditions of the elevated terrace of the 10th floor as well as a study of the solar light reflectivity impact of the new façade of this development. This was followed by wind tunnel studies of the wind loads on the structure and cladding. This structure is particularly sensitive to the wind loads due to the fact that a significant portion of the base of the tower cantilevers over the existing heritage podium building. A wind entry study was also undertaken for the main lobby entries as well as an assessment of wind-noise and design wind loads acting on the artwork attached to the external facade.

The Era Apartments development located at 7 Railway St, Chatswood, is the final stage of the Pacific Place development by Mirvac. Windtech provided the wind engineering services for all the towers within this development precinct.

Windtech undertook a comprehensive pedestrian wind environment study for all the outdoor areas associated with the entire Pacific Place precinct as well as all outdoor areas within and around the Era Apartments development, including the various balconies. Windtech worked closely with the design team at Mirvac to ensure that all wind mitigation measures also contribute to an improved aesthetic for the affected outdoor areas and public spaces. Mitigation measures for the north-western balconies also improved thermal comfort performance off the adjacent apartments. Windtech also modelled and advised regarding the natural ventilation performance for all the apartments as well as the design wind loads on the structure and facade. The potential for wind entry at the main entrance as well as wind noise and lift pressurisation within this apartment tower was also modelled and appropriate mitigation measures were incorporated into the design. Windtech also assessed and advised on solar access to the apartments, shadows as well as solar light reflectivity impacts.

Pacific Bondi Beach is located directly opposite Bondi Beach and is exposed to both the prevailing southerly and north-easterly winds. This development is a conversion of the Swiss Grand Hotel Suites into residential apartments and incorporates an additional above the original building envelope. Windtech advised regarding wind entry as well as the design wind pressures for the extension.


As of March 2017, all new apartments developed in Victoria must meet the newly introduced Better Apartments Design Standards. These policy guidelines will influence the design of apartment development in Melbourne for years to come.

 

 

A key objective of the new standards is energy efficiency for all dwellings. New developments must reduce fossil fuel energy use and make appropriate use of daylight and solar energy to ensure that they achieve adequate thermal efficiency.

To ensure energy efficiency, developments must not exceed the specified maximum NatHERS annual cooling load. NatHERS is the Nationwide House Energy Rating Scheme which ensures dwellings are comfortable for its residents while also helping save on energy bills through smarter design choices. Windtech can ensure that each dwelling within the development satisfies the specified maximum NatHERS annual cooling load.

 

 

Windtech Consultants has extensive experience in undertaking energy efficiency studies through the use of industry standard NatHERS software (BERS Pro). Windtech has researched the comparative costs of different paths for compliance and is therefore well equipped to assist both developers and designers to determine the most cost effective solutions to satisfy the energy efficiency component of the Better Apartments Design Standards. 

BASIX Certificates in New South Wales

Windtech has many years’ of experience determining the energy efficiency of residential buildings and has assisted numerous developers and designers to achieve compliance with BASIX assessment standards in New South Wales.

The Building Sustainability Index (Basix) aims to deliver equitable and effective water and greenhouse gas reduction through efficient design of the development. Thermal modelling of the residential components of the development are made to determine the amount of energy that each dwelling requires to maintain thermal comfort throughout the year. If it is established that a dwelling does not meet the thermal performance criteria, various forms of treatments will be added to the thermal model in consultation with the client and/or architect. Windtech staff are highly skilled in understanding the comparative costs of alternative paths to achieve compliance and does not charge extra for this additional modelling.

BASIX also helps reduce water and energy consumption therefore providing substantial long term financial savings and sustainability. BASIX certification is mandatory for all residential developments in NSW.

Whether you are in need of meeting the Better Apartments Design Standards in Victoria, or a BASIX assessment in New South Wales, Windtech can provide a prompt, experienced and cost effective service today.

Neighbours of new developments and local government authorities are becoming increasingly aware of the potential impacts of solar reflectivity, whether in terms of visible light or thermal reflectance. To prevent such risks, Windtech Consultants carries out assessments of both visible light and thermal reflectance to predict and mitigate these effects before they happen.

Two of the most well-known projects in terms of solar thermal reflectance impact is the ‘Walkie Talkie’ high rise development in London, UK and the VDARA Hotel, Las Vegas.  The concave form of the curtain wall façade of these developments concentrated solar reflections, increasing the intensity of both light and heat.  The intensity was so severe in the instance of the ‘walkie talkie’ building that there was damage to nearby vehicles. This included warping of the exterior of these vehicles, as well as melting plastic components. In the case of the VDARA Hotel, there were reports that people received severe sunburns and that the outdoor pool temperature rose by 20 degrees. This effect is similar to pointing a magnifying glass to an object located close to the focal point of the lens.

To prevent such risks, Windtech Consultants carries out thermal reflectance modelling to predict these effects. An example is the detailed analysis into the solar thermal reflectance of the high rise structure proposed for 104-114 Scarborough St, Southport, Queensland. The analysis focused on the impact of solar thermal reflectance from the façade of the proposed development on the surrounding streets below.

Two seasonal cases were studied, namely autumn and summer, which are the most critical for solar thermal reflectance. The thermal conditions were assessed for a 12 hour period in total, ranging from 6:00am up until 6:00pm for the aforementioned seasons.

The analysis involved a hybrid approach, whereby a numerical model was generated using a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) package which was then combined with desktop calculations of occupant comfort parameters; namely the Standard Effective Temperature (SET), Predicted Mean Vote (PMV) as well as the Predicted Percentage Dissatisfied (PPD). These have been shown to more closely reflect a person’s perception of temperature. Additionally, occupant safety was also assessed by means of comparing the findings of the analysis against guidelines set out by the US organisation’s Federal Emergency Management Association (FEMA) as well as the US National Fire Protection Association (NFPA).  Furthermore, an assessment was made of the background thermal conditions of the surrounding streetscapes (without the proposed building) to properly gauge the impact of the proposed development.

In recent times, the installation of paver pedestal systems for outdoor areas of building developments has increased in popularity. The noted advantages include, water damage prevention (reduced membrane deterioration) and reduced heat conductivity to the area below. Designers have assumed in the past that the net pressures on these pavers would tend to equalise due to surface pressure being transferred to the cavity below. However, this assumption has been proven to not hold particularly when the pavers are subject to significant accelerated flows around the corners of the base of a tower, where it meets with the podium or conical vertices at the corners of roof top terraces. These wind flow structures can generate a significant net uplift pressure sufficient to overcome the self-weight of some of the largest and heaviest loose-laid pavers. This can result in damage to the pavers from localised movement to larger impacts where such pavers can be uplifted and become wind borne.

The loose-laid pavers are lifted when the net pressure between the top and bottom surface of the paver is sufficiently negative to overcome the gravitation load holding the paver in place. As the vortices pass over the middle of a given paver, the pressure propagates to the cavity underneath via the open edges. However, the transfer of the negative (suction) upper surface pressure to the underside of the paver is incomplete, resulting in an underside surface pressure that is significantly less negative and this leads to the paver lifting.

Windtech Consultants have undertaken full-scale paver lift-off studies for various configurations of loose-laid pedestal paving systems to understand the relationship between the net uplift pressure that causes the pavers to lift and the paver density, dimensions and the depth of the cavity below the pavers.

To be able to provide the client with an understanding of the risk, or expected mean recurrence period for paver lift-off, a wind tunnel study of the subject development is undertaken. The various areas proposed to be covered with the loose-laid pavers are instrumented with pressure sensors to determine the wind pressure acting on the top surface (typically a podium or roof terrace area) for 36 wind directions. The measured pressures acting on these areas are then combined with a directional probability wind climate model for the region and the full-scale measurements for the given paver system to derive a return period (risk) for lift-off of the pavers for the proposed system. This enables the client to have a complete understanding of the problematic areas and/or risks associated with the area, and implement mitigation measures for areas that pose unacceptably high risk, should this be required.

Example of a full-sale test of a pedestal paver system.